Chapter 6

Phase 3: Integration

Overview

6.1 Where Protocols Meet Physics

A wireless charger is a protocol machine wrapped around a magnetic circuit. The coils move the energy, but the protocol decides when that energy may flow, how much of it, and when it must stop. Phase 3 of WIA-COMM-008 defines those exchanges for inductive coupling, magnetic resonance, Qi, AirFuel, SAE J2954 and the foreign-object-detection (FOD) shutdown path. The earlier phases fixed the data envelopes and the interfaces that expose them. This phase specifies the sequences that run across the transmitter (Tx) and receiver (Rx) boundary, which is the point where two products from different vendors have to agree.

Three design stances recur through the phase:

The sections below follow that order: the link-level foundation, the market tiers it creates, the applications that use each tier, the safety and compliance machinery, practical implementation concerns, and the directions the specification leaves open.

Technical Foundation

6.2 Link Protocols and the Loss Budget

Inductive coupling. The inductive protocol governs magnetic-induction transfer between Tx and Rx coils at a documented operating frequency. Designers choose between fixed-frequency operation, as in Qi v1.x and J2954, and variable-frequency operation, which some proprietary chargers use to track receiver power. In Qi the Rx talks to the Tx by in-band ASK at 2 kbps. Those packets carry control, error and end-power-transfer messages. The protocol also enforces a maximum-coupling envelope, so a receiver cannot present a low-impedance load that overheats the Tx coil.

Magnetic resonance. The resonant protocol uses a high-Q link at 6.78 MHz for AirFuel, or at proprietary frequencies. A BLE side channel handles discovery and control. The Tx runs an impedance-tracking loop and must tolerate resonator detuning as components drift thermally. When several receivers share a field, each reports its accepted power and the Tx adjusts duty cycle and impedance match. That keeps the total inside the Tx coil's thermal budget.

The Qi session. A Qi exchange under WPC v1.3 / v2.0 (with QiPlus extensions) moves through these steps:

  1. Receiver detection by analog ping, then digital ping.
  2. Receiver identification.
  3. Configuration and power transfer, including the FOD calibration sequence.
  4. Renegotiation when the Rx asks for more power, for example the 5 W to 9 W to 15 W upgrade path of v1.2.4 BPP/EPP.
  5. An end-power-transfer (EPT) packet that closes the session with a documented end-reason code.

The AirFuel session. It starts with BLE discovery (the legacy A4WP profile) and a resonator activation handshake. A charge-control state machine then cycles through sense, charge, regulate and fault. Multiple devices are served by round-robin scheduling, with control that cancels coupling between receivers in the same field. Keeping BLE control apart from 6.78 MHz power simplifies coordination, at the price of BLE-stack latency.

FamilyPower-channel frequencyControl pathNotable mechanism
Qi (inductive)Fixed-frequency operationIn-band ASK, Rx to Tx, 2 kbpsPing, identify, configure, renegotiate, EPT
AirFuel (resonant)6.78 MHzBLE side channelSense / charge / regulate / fault state machine
SAE J2954 (EV)79–90 kHzIn-band sideband per SAE J2847/6WPT classes and Z alignment categories

The loss budget. Efficiency is defined at the two ends of the link, and every protocol decision shows up in it:

η = (P_out / P_in) × 100%

P_loss_coil = I² × R
P_loss_core = k_h × f × B² + k_e × f² × B²
P_loss_rect = V_f × I + I² × R_on

Here k_h and k_e are the hysteresis and eddy-current coefficients, f is frequency, B is flux density, V_f is the rectifier forward drop and R_on is the on-resistance. Five levers recover efficiency: impedance matching, resonance tuning, alignment, high-Q coils (litz wire with ferrite shielding) and active rectification with synchronous FETs in place of diodes. Each of them is a physical setting that the protocol must be able to hold steady while the load changes.

Market Analysis

6.3 Power Tiers and the Distance Trade-Off

The specification's typical-efficiency table is a compact view of how the market divides. Each tier trades coupling distance against efficiency and power, and each is served by a different protocol family.

Power levelTechnologyEfficiencyDistance
5 WQi BPP70–75%3–5 mm
15 WQi EPP75–80%3–8 mm
50 WAirFuel65–75%10–50 mm
11 kWSAE J295485–90%100–200 mm

Three observations follow from the table. First, the closest-range tiers are not the most efficient. The 11 kW vehicle tier is, because its large, carefully aligned, high-Q coils keep losses low even across a 100–200 mm gap. Second, the AirFuel tier gives up some efficiency to gain spatial freedom, which is what makes multi-device charging in one field practical. Third, a Qi charger at the low end must also be cheap, so its design leans on the protocol to keep a simple coil safe rather than on expensive hardware.

This commercial split explains the dual-mode charger. A product that advertises both Qi and AirFuel performs an analog ping and a BLE discovery at receiver detection and follows whichever side answers. The protocol forbids running both on the same coil at once, because cross-protocol RF interference would degrade both. A multi-coil array may run different protocols on different coils, provided the documented inter-coil isolation envelope holds. A worked example: a charger measures 7 W in and the receiver reports 5 W out. The link is at about 71%, inside the 70–75% band expected for Qi BPP, so no inefficiency alarm is warranted.

Industry Applications

6.4 Phones, Shared Surfaces and Vehicles

Handheld devices. The 5 W and 15 W Qi tiers serve phones and similar devices. Here the main practical problem is human placement. Lateral misalignment lowers the coupling coefficient roughly as a Gaussian in the offset:

k(Δx) ≈ k₀ × exp(-α × Δx²)

k₀ is coupling at perfect alignment and α is a decay constant set by coil geometry. Because efficiency falls off quadratically and the device may stop meeting its power requirement, chargers give the user feedback:

More advanced products remove the user from the loop with passive magnets, motor-driven coil positioning, camera-based computer vision, or multiple coils with adaptive selection.

Shared surfaces. Resonant charging lets several receivers draw from one field. The Tx has to arbitrate. Round-robin scheduling and per-receiver accepted-power reports prevent one device from starving the others or pushing the coil past its thermal limit.

Electric vehicles. SAE J2954 defines three power classes: WPT 1 (3.7 kW), WPT 2 (7.7 kW) and WPT 3 (11.1 kW). Vehicles are sorted into alignment categories Z1, Z2 and Z3 by ground clearance (small, medium and large). Messaging rides the WPT control channel in LIN/CAN-mapped form under SAE J2847/6. The IEC 61980 series is cross-referenced for harmonised deployment in the EU. The standard also recognises dynamic and opportunistic charging, but only as an experimental envelope for proposals on instrumented road segments.

Standards Compliance

6.5 FOD, Shutdown and Safety Envelopes

Foreign objects such as coins, keys and other metal can heat dangerously (above 100 °C), reduce efficiency, damage the charger or receiver, and create safety hazards. WIA-COMM-008 defines three independent detection methods, each with a threshold.

MethodQuantityThreshold indicating a foreign object
Q-factor measurementΔQ = (Q_baseline − Q_measured) / Q_baselineΔQ above 10%
Power lossP_loss = P_in − P_out − P_expected_lossP_loss above 1 W
Frequency detuningΔf = f_baseline − f_measuredΔf above 2%

The Qi implementation follows four steps: calibrate a baseline Q with no object present, monitor continuously, cut power on detection, and notify the user by LED, beep or app alert. The baseline-calibration step is part of the Qi v1.3 calibration sequence, and the Tx stores its no-receiver Q as the reference for the differential test. The implementation notes sample Q every second, while the protocol clause describes a typical re-test cadence of 200–500 ms during active charging. A designer should treat the faster figure as the target for the safety path and the slower one as an upper bound for simple designs.

The shutdown sequence is ordered so that the system is never left in an ambiguous state:

1. graceful power-down
2. BLE / in-band notification to the receiver
3. session-state transition
4. audit-log emission

The same sequence fires on thermal violations. For Qi the typical maximum coil temperature is 70–80 °C, while J2954 specifies its own thermal envelope per WPT class. It also fires on alignment loss, where the response must come in under a second once alignment exceeds policy.

One housekeeping point concerns versioning rather than physics. Within the 1.x line, existing envelopes, endpoints and protocol exchanges stay reachable and keep their documented behaviour, and implementations may add optional fields but not remove existing ones. A reference container and a conformance test suite let integrators exercise these exchanges before connecting real backends.

Implementation Considerations

6.6 Coils, Heat and a Trustworthy Control Plane

Coil design and Q calibration. Per-coil parameters include turn count, conductor choice, ferrite shielding geometry and encapsulation. Litz wire in AWG 38, 42 or 46, with strand counts in the hundreds, keeps skin-effect losses down. Typical measured Q is 300–1500 for high-Q resonant coils and 100–300 for inductive Qi coils at the operating frequency. Because FOD depends on the differential against baseline Q, the calibration must be temperature-compensated. Otherwise a warm room can look like a metal object and cause a false-positive shutdown.

Thermal control. Heat comes from four places: I²R coil loss, hysteresis and eddy-current core loss, rectifier dissipation, and induced currents in foreign objects. NTC thermistors embedded in the Tx coil are sampled at 1–10 Hz, and temperature follows:

T = β / ln(R/R₀) - 273.15

Here β is the NTC beta coefficient in kelvin, R is the measured resistance and R₀ is the resistance at 25 °C.

ComponentWarningCutoff
Transmitter coil70 °C80 °C
Receiver coil70 °C80 °C
Rectifier100 °C125 °C
Battery (lithium-ion)40 °C45 °C
Foreign objectN/A100 °C

Mitigations are applied from the cheapest upward. They are dynamic power scaling, duty-cycle control with cooling intervals, forced air for high-power units, heatsinks of aluminium or copper, and thermal pads to the chassis. Note that the battery limits are far lower than the coil limits. A charger that respects its own coil but ignores the cell it is feeding is not compliant in spirit.

Control-plane integrity. Management traffic uses a 96-bit nonce, a 300-second skew window and a 600-second seen-nonce cache to defeat replay. Telemetry runs over mTLS with per-channel monotonic counters, and the broker drops replayed messages. The BLE side channel uses Bluetooth Secure Connections pairing per Bluetooth Core Spec 5.x, with the operator documenting the mode chosen: Just Works, Numeric Comparison, Passkey Entry or Out-of-Band. Just Works offers no protection against an active attacker, so exposed chargers should prefer a stronger mode.

Future Outlook

6.7 Open Directions in the Specification

The specification marks a few areas as still maturing, and each follows from a limit described above.

The backwards-compatibility rule is what makes these extensions safe to adopt. New capability arrives as optional fields and new envelopes, so a charger built today can interoperate with the receivers that follow it.

Review Questions

6.8 Exercises

  1. A Qi charger records a baseline Q of 200. During charging it measures 170. Compute ΔQ and state whether the Q-factor method flags a foreign object.
  2. A receiver reports 5 W out while the transmitter draws 7 W. Compute η. Is it consistent with the typical Qi BPP range, and what would you check first if it were much lower?
  3. Explain why the 11 kW J2954 tier achieves higher efficiency than the 5 W Qi tier despite a gap of 100–200 mm.
  4. Why does the specification forbid activating Qi and AirFuel simultaneously on one Tx coil, and how may a multi-coil array still serve both?
  5. Describe the four ordered steps of the controlled shutdown sequence. Why does audit-log emission come last?
  6. A ΔQ reading rises steadily as the room warms, but the power-loss method shows nothing unusual. Which calibration feature should prevent a false shutdown, and which method would you trust?
  7. Using the lateral-misalignment model, what happens to k if Δx doubles? Explain why the loss in efficiency is described as quadratic.
  8. The coil is at 72 °C and the battery is at 41 °C. Which thresholds have been crossed, and which mitigations apply first?

Summary

6.9 Recap and the Road to the Ecosystem Layer

Phase 3 turns the physics of wireless charging into exchanges that independent vendors can implement. Inductive coupling relies on in-band ASK at 2 kbps. Resonant charging pairs 6.78 MHz power with a BLE side channel. Qi sessions move from analog and digital ping through identification and renegotiation to a clean EPT close. J2954 adds power classes, alignment categories and a vehicle-grade control channel. Beneath all of it sits one loss budget (coil, core and rectifier) that explains the efficiency table and the five optimisation levers.

Safety is the thread that ties the phase together. Three FOD methods use thresholds of 10% for ΔQ, 1 W for unexplained loss and 2% for frequency shift. Temperature limits are set per component, from the 70/80 °C coil limits down to the 40/45 °C battery limits. A fixed shutdown order ends every unsafe session, and an uncertain measurement always resolves toward less power. Replay defences and BLE pairing keep the control plane from being used to defeat those protections.

The next chapter moves outward from individual protocol exchanges to the wider ecosystem. It looks at how a charger that already behaves correctly on its own link fits among the other systems that depend on it.